Rhona is a legal pricing specialist with cross-sector experience across leading law firms and global in-house teams. With deep insight into both sides of the market, she brings a strategic, commercially minded approach to legal pricing, helping align law firm delivery with client expectations and build stronger partnerships through data, collaboration and innovation.

“We all know by now that legal AI challenges the traditional hourly rate. But what’s more interesting is that it forces clients and law firms to become far more deliberate about the value they’re trying to create together.”

When I think about value, I don’t immediately think about legal services or pricing models.

I think about coffee.

There is a specialist coffee shop I visit where I happily pay more for a flat white than I would elsewhere. Objectively, the outcome is the same. I still walk away with a coffee. But I’m prepared to pay more because, to me, it’s more valuable. It might be the quality, consistency, service or simply the confidence that I know exactly what I’m going to get.

The outcome is the same. The value isn’t.

One of the things I find most interesting about value is how often it’s treated as something objective. It’s not that straightforward.

Different clients value different things. For some, it’s speed. For others, it’s budget certainty. Some prioritise specialist expertise. Others value strategic insight, proactive thinking or advisers who understand their business well enough to identify issues before they become problems.

After years of working in legal pricing, I can tell you that value sits at the heart of most of the important decisions clients make yet it remains one of the hardest things to define. With AI forcing the legal industry to rethink some of its most deeply held assumptions about delivery and pricing, understanding what value really means has become even more important.

Whilst AI changes how legal expertise is delivered, it doesn’t change why clients buy legal services in the first place. If anything, it brings that question into sharper focus.

A lawyer using a copilot is still a lawyer delivering legal advice, just more efficiently. The more clients and firms move beyond discussions about inputs, the more space there is to talk about outcomes, risk, priorities and what success actually looks like. When there is no obvious input to price, clients have little choice but to focus on the outcome and that’s where the most valuable discussions happen. Define and communicate the desired outcome first, and law firms are in a much stronger position to build bespoke pricing and delivery models around a client’s objectives and definition of success.

The Certainty Conversation

One conversation comes to mind. A client approached us with a new matter, a defined scope and an ambitious deadline. Like most pricing proposals, it started with a request for a fee proposal. On the surface, it looked like a question about cost.

As we explored the scope further, it became clear that the client wasn’t looking for the cheapest option. They were looking for certainty. They wanted confidence that the matter would be delivered within budget, with no surprises, and that they could rely on the judgement and advice they were receiving. They wanted to know that the people supporting them understood what success looked like to them. What started as a conversation about numbers quickly became about risk, predictability and outcomes.

We explored different pricing approaches, including a shared risk arrangement and an outcome-based model where part of the fee was linked to achieving a successful result. The discussion became less about cost and more about aligning incentives, expectations and outcomes.

Clients often know what they don’t want. Unexpected invoices, delays and unnecessary complexity rarely feature on anyone’s wish list. The more productive conversations happen when clients are equally clear about what they do want even if it’s not easy to define.

It also creates responsibility on both sides. In my experience, the clients who get the most value from their outside counsel are not the ones who arrive with every answer. More often, they are the ones comfortable saying:

“This is the problem we’re trying to solve but we’re not entirely sure what the best solution looks like.”

That creates the kind of collaboration the industry needs at a time when AI is moving faster than any of us can keep up with.

The Efficiency Trap

Historically, legal services have been priced around inputs, most commonly time. That model works when technology simply helps lawyers work faster. But what happens when technology starts carrying out increasingly large parts of the process itself.

As firms become more efficient, there will inevitably be matters where they benefit from stronger margins, and they should. Equally, there will be opportunities to offer clients more competitive pricing where technology reduces the cost of delivery. The future is unlikely to be a world where every efficiency is retained by the law firm or passed entirely to the client. The real opportunity lies in creating models where both sides share in the value created.

The reality is most firms are designed to operate across multiple sectors, jurisdictions, practice areas and client types. No single delivery model or pricing approach will perfectly reflect the priorities of every client. That’s why the future is likely to be a world where we spend less time discussing inputs and more time focusing on outputs, outcomes and shared value. We all know by now that legal AI challenges the traditional hourly rate. But what’s more interesting is that it forces clients and law firms to become far more deliberate about the value they’re trying to create together.

That demands trust from both sides. The clients most open to those conversations are often not those looking for the lowest fee; they are the ones focused on achieving the right outcome and recognising that speed, certainty, strategic judgement and reduced risk can create more value than the legal fee itself.

The Real Opportunity

To me, the most interesting thing about this moment is that nobody has all the answers.

Law firms are still working out what AI enabled delivery models look like. Clients are still determining what they expect from them. Technology providers continue to evolve at a remarkable pace.

The models will continue to evolve and that’s a good thing. They have the potential to make legal services more accessible, more efficient and more innovative than ever before.

But buying the technology is only the start. The real opportunity is in understanding how it creates value for your business. Ask your outside counsel how they’re using AI, where they see the biggest opportunities and what it could mean for your objectives. Be clear about what success looks like for you.

The clients that benefit most from legal AI will be the ones having better conversations about value.